A Head-to-Head Test of Four Practices
The trial, published in the journal Cell Reports Medicine in January 2023, took a careful, comparative approach. The researchers recruited 111 healthy adult volunteers and randomly assigned each person to one of four daily practices: cyclic sighing, box breathing, cyclic hyperventilation, or mindfulness meditation. Everyone practiced their assigned technique for about five minutes a day across roughly a month.
To capture what was happening, the team used well-established tools rather than vague impressions. Participants completed the State Anxiety Inventory and the Positive and Negative Affect Schedule before and after each session, two standardized questionnaires that measure current anxiety and the balance of good and difficult feelings. People also wore sensors that tracked their resting breathing rate and heart rate, so the study could pair how participants said they felt with measurable signals from their bodies.
The four practices each ask something different of you, which is part of what makes the comparison so useful.
The Result That Caught People's Attention
Here is the encouraging part: every single group improved. All three breathing styles and the meditation group reported less anxiety and better mood over the month. Mindfulness worked, exactly as decades of research would predict. So the breathing techniques were not being measured against doing nothing — they were measured against a practice already known to help.
Even so, the controlled-breathing groups pulled ahead on positive mood. On average, they recorded a daily increase in positive affect of about 1.91 points on the questionnaire scale, compared with about 1.22 points for the mindfulness group — an improvement roughly a third larger. And among all four practices, cyclic sighing produced the greatest daily lift in positive feelings. The effect also tended to grow as the month went on, so the more consecutive days people practiced, the more their mood seemed to benefit.
The body data told a matching story. Cyclic sighing brought the largest reduction in resting breathing rate, more than meditation or the other two breathing styles. People were breathing more slowly not only during their five minutes of practice but throughout the day, a sign that the calm was carrying over. Interestingly, the study found no meaningful change in heart rate in any group, which keeps the claim precise: this was a shift in breathing and mood, not a wholesale change in cardiovascular function. And the two threads were linked — the people whose breathing slowed the most were generally the ones who felt the biggest gains in positive mood.